- TripAdvisor annual certificates of excellence for dining and lodging
- Read this wonderful article from The New York Times
- The American Hotel has been featured on Rachael Ray’s $40 a Day, Rachael’s Tasty Travels, and on HGTV’s Restore America.
- Read the terrific Daily Mail article from May 2017!
- The American Hotel Restaurant was recently honored by hosting a dinner for the Albany Chaine des Rotisseurs in May, 2016.
- The New York State Office Of Parks, Recreation & Historic Preservation Award 2003
- The Preservation League Of New York State Excellence In Historic Preservation Award 2002
- The Otsego & Schoharie County Preservation Award 2002
A gem Everyone (3 couples) tasted their appetizer soups, fried calamari, salmon and said, “Oh, that’s really good.” For entrees, we got lamp chops, charbroiled salmon, turkey dinner and fish and chips: all thoroughly delicious and enjoyed. Although full, we couldn’t resist 3 different cakes and a baklava for dessert. The menu is sufficiently varied, the portions generous, the prices reasonable and the staff friendly and accommodating. The restaurant is a gem and we will return.Posted on Tripadvisor
Shari DSeptember 6, 2026.Beautiful B&B with great food and staff Gorgeous B&B in a small town 20 minutes from Glimmerglass Opera and the Baseball Hall of Fame. Lovely grounds and a very personable owner and staff made our stay a pleasure. Dinner was probably the best in the area, and the included breakfast was hearty and well done. It's not a Hampton or Hilton, which is part of its charm. We were in Room 1, the only room on the ground floor, which made bringing our luggage in easy. It also had direct access to the front porch.Posted on Tripadvisor
Jerry SJuly 30, 2026.Such a lovely Bed and Breakfast! We enjoyed a delicious dinner,make sure you save room for the homemade desserts, and an even more delicious breakfast the next day! Michael and his entire staff were welcoming, friendly and lots of fun! Thank you for a memorable nightPosted on Tripadvisor
Tracey EJune 23, 2026.Outstanding Restaurant in lovely village We have had two celebratory dinners at the American Hotel Restaurant. Both were outstanding. The crab cakes are the best I’ve had anywhere. The fried green tomatoes and collard greens are excellent, with just the right amount of spice! We also enjoyed very attentive service, from the waitstaff to one of the owners stopping by to check on everything. I like that they have food at a variety of price points, from sandwiches to steak.Posted on Tripadvisor
mkfisher66November 13, 2025.A very pleasant meal We went just for dinner. We used to go when it was under the direction of the former owners so we were trying to keep an open mind and not compare it to “the way it used to be”. The menu is limited but of the items we tried we were not disappointed. There was a little something for everyone. All of our entrees were cooked to perfection and nicely seasoned. The portions were just right, leaving just enough room for coffee and dessert. We will be back! Most enjoyable!Posted on Tripadvisor
Bumble’s momNovember 2, 2025.Wonderful, cozy getaway with great restaurant! My elderly mother, young daughter and I stayed in room 3. The room is perfect for two people. (My daughter was a last minute addition.) We had a fantastic stay and can't rave enough about how kind, responsive and generous the owners and staff were. The hotel itself is charming -- thoughtfully decorated and cozy. The lobby bar and lounge create a social atmosphere if you don't want to stay holed up in your room. The restaurant is excellent -- we enjoyed a delicious dinner, cocktail, and the included breakfast is top-notch. It has ample outdoor space for socializing, strolling, or reading a good book. There are a few shops right across the street that you can browse. Highly recommend for a romantic getaway, trip with your favorite person, or a solo retreat.Posted on Tripadvisor
MellowYazNYAugust 11, 2025.Wonderful Small Town Experience! We stayed at this quaint hotel during our visit to Cooperstown for the Hall of Fame Weekend. Our experience was really enjoyable. Michael Palaia and Marco Braeutigam have working hard to put together a quality experience at this renovated inn which is on the National Register of Historic Places and thus far the results are fantastic! The rooms are small but comfortable with individual bathrooms and room appropriate refrigerators stocked with water and small boxes of local chocolate. The bathrooms also featured Beekman bath products from the famous local producer with a store across the street. The sit-down breakfast each morning was delicious and featured such items as ricotta pancakes with blueberry compote, scrambled eggs with various veggies and cheese, and French toast. All items could be ordered with bacon or sausage too! They also recently began their dinner service and we enjoyed a delicious and reasonably priced dinner also served in the lovely and comfortable hotel dining room. We did not have time to sit on their vast porch or in the beautiful garden but hopefully next time we will allow time to linger and enjoy this beautiful property. The staff (Michael, Linda, Veronica, etc.) are wonderful and go out of the way to make you feel at home. We eagerly look forward to our return!Posted on Tripadvisor
D CAugust 11, 2025.Awesome food! The American hotel has reopened with new owners and a wonderful updated menu. The menu is going to be expanding but they have something for everyone. The service is excellent, and the restaurant can best be described as classy. Wonderful decor! Wonderful servers and owners! We did not use the hotel rooms and I have seen photos and they look lovely. A terrific new restaurant for the area that was greatly needed!Posted on Tripadvisor
Navigate55582185992August 5, 2025.New owners doing an AMAZING job! We went for dinner. They are still in their soft opening phase but my goodness! The food was AMAZING! The owner was absolutely wonderful. The prior owners were a very tough act to follow BUT kudos The new owners are just as welcoming and the food will knock your socks off. Menu has a southern flair. I had crab cakes that were pure crab and SO much flavor! So happy the American Hotel is continuing its excellencePosted on TripadvisorNicole MJuly 31, 2025.